Power Four Football and Academics
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.65150/EP-jsshrs/V2E8/2026-09Keywords:
play for pay, student athlete, transfer portal, NIL, and academics.Abstract
The evolution of Power Football Conferences evolved from a past history where college football players and other college athletes were students who participated in athletics in an exchange for a scholarship that covered their tuition, supplies and housing. In the current evolution of college sports amateurism is dead. The athletes are compensated for their services and are completely free agents to transfer. They are no longer student athletes. The athletes are free to sell their services to the highest bidder and transfer for a better offer and more playing time.
The issue is should academic institutions be in the professional sports business and given the exploding costs what are the benefits, if any, to an academic institution. The benefits currently reside with the coaches, players, and athletic programs.
References
1) AAU.edu (2023) Membership
2) AAU Outlines Concerns About Massive Cuts in FY26 Presidential Budget Report, May 2, 2025a, AAU.
3) Annual Report on the Economic Status of the Profession, 2024-23025, June 2025b, AAU
4) Armato, Leonard (December 16, 2022), “Pay for Play is Alive in College Sports and Free Agency has Arrived”, Forbes.
5) Bachman, Rachel (June 30, 2025), The College Sports Gold Rush is About to Run into a Brick Wall, WSJ.
6) Baker, Matt (July 22, 2025), What are College Football Programs Actually Worth? NYTimes.
7) Besanko, David, Dranove, David, Shanley, Mark, and Scarfer, Scott (216), Economics of Strategy, seventh edition, Wiley.
8) Bilas, Jay (June 29, 2022), “Why NIL has Been Good for College Sports and the Hurdles That Remain”, ESPN.
9) Brown, J.R. (2022),” Game theory and the Farmer’s Federation of Western North Carolina”, Sage Business Cases.
10) Dinich, Heather (September 6, 2023), “Many Schools on Track to Spend More on Coaches Than Player’s Needs”, ESPN.
11) Economist (May 19, 2018), “How Global University Rankings are Changing Higher Education”.
12) Higgins, Laine (November 19-20, 2022), “Miami Offered Recruits Big Deals Then Canes Started Losing”, Wall Street Journal.
13) Jeyarajah, Shelan (June 7, 2025), “How college athletes will be paid after House v. NCAA settlement: NIL changes, enforcement, contracts, and more”, CBS Sports
14) Kealey, Patrick, Shastri, Yatin, Battistini, Francisco, Durrell, Tyler, Huh, Jeong, and Agha, Nola (2018), “Bloomberg Sports: Information Goes Abroad”, Sage Business Cases.
15) MacIntosh, John (July 10,223), “Opinion: The One Group with a Huge Advantage in College Admissions”, CNN.
16) Murphy, Dan (June 6, 2025), Judge OK’s $2.8 B settlement, paving the way for colleges to pay athletes, ESPN.
17) Nietzel, Michael T. (January 13, 2025), Power Five Universities Spend Much More Per Athlete Than for Other Students, Finds New Study.
18) Norlander, Matt (July 2023), “Transfer Portal, NIL Reshaping College, Basketball Recruiting has Dropped Value of High School Prospects”, CBS Sports.
19) NCAA. Com (2023), “FBS Football Championship History”.
20) NCAA Revenue Sharing & NIL Estimates 2025 (2025), NIL-NCAA.com.
21) Randazzo, Sara (May 17-18, 2025), “Pay cuts, layoffs hit universities”, Wall Street Journal.
22) Rizzuto-Flancbaum, Zen (December 4, 2024), “Athletic Departments as a Business: Antitrust Concerns Surrounding Private Equity in Collegiate Sports”, Jeffrey S. Moorad Center for the Study of Sports Law.
23) Robinson, Doug (July 29, 2023), “College Sports the Business That’s Like No Other”, Desert News.
24) Schrotenboer, Brent (June 23, 2025), Cuts of Consequence, USA Today.
25) Stefanik, Andrew (October 10, 2023”, “Mark Stoops Urges Fans to Donate More to Help Kentucky Get better Players”, Kentucky Radio Network.
26) Talty, John (June 7, 2025),” The biggest winners and losers from House v. NCAA settlement: amateurism is dead and the class divide grows”, ESPN.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Arthur Kraft, John Kraft (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
